Why are perfume and wine so alike?
By Arthur Cukier
Short answer: perfume and wine are two of the very few worlds where pure agriculture, chemistry and high luxury live together. Both start with a plant and a place. Both depend on how that plant is transformed and blended. And both travel the world in alcohol.
I grew up between the two. My mother's family made and distributed wine. My father distributed perfume. The longer I work in perfume, the more alike they look to me.
Three worlds that rarely meet
Farming, chemistry and luxury usually do not talk to each other. In wine and perfume, they have to. A bad harvest changes the product. A new extraction method opens new scents. And the final bottle is sold as a luxury.
It starts with the raw material
In both worlds, the French learned over centuries to pay attention to the raw ingredient: where it grows, the soil, the climate, the year. A grape from one hill is not the grape from the next one. An iris root from Tuscany is not the same as one grown elsewhere.
Italy has some of my favourite materials. Bergamot from Calabria is one of them: bright, citrusy, a little fruity. It is one of my favourite ingredients ever, and we use it a lot in Borsalino.
Then comes the transformation
Wine makers ferment. Perfumers distil, extract and macerate. In both cases the method changes everything. Perfume houses keep looking for new ways to distil a material and bring out a facet nobody has smelled before. Maceration, leaving materials to rest together, creates new scents, just as time in the barrel changes a wine.
Blending and concentration
A wine maker blends grapes and plots. A perfumer blends materials. Concentration matters in both: an Eau de Toilette and an Eau de Parfum Intense are not the same experience, just as a light red and a great vintage are not.
The same headaches
Both products are made with alcohol. Perfume is classed as a flammable dangerous good for transport. So shipping it around the world brings the same kind of rules, costs and risks that wine people know well.
Noses and sommeliers
This is why I love working with perfumers. They remind me of the people I met in wine: a sommelier who can name a plot from one sip, or a wine maker in a château who knows each barrel. Same patience. Same respect for the material. Same words for things most people only feel.
Wine and perfume, side by side
- Raw material: grapes / flowers, roots, woods, resins.
- Place: terroir / origin of the material (Tuscan iris, Calabrian bergamot, Grasse rose).
- Transformation: fermentation and ageing / distillation, extraction, maceration.
- Craft: blending grapes / blending materials.
- The expert: wine maker and sommelier / perfumer, the nose.
- Carrier: alcohol, in both.
Questions we often hear
Why are perfume and wine compared so often?
Both turn an agricultural raw material into a luxury product through chemistry and craft, both depend on origin and blending, and both are carried in alcohol.
Is there terroir in perfume?
Yes. The origin of a natural material changes its smell. Iris from Tuscany or rose from Grasse are valued for where they grow, like grapes from a great vineyard.
What is maceration in perfume?
Letting materials rest together over time so the scent rounds out and new facets appear, a little like ageing a wine.
Is a perfumer like a sommelier?
In many ways. Both train their nose for years, know their materials deeply and put words on what most people only feel.